If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my rss feed. Thanks for visiting!
Today’s guest post is courtesy of Charlotte of The Great Fitness Experiment. Charlotte also blogs at The Huffington Post.
In my line of work (can I actually call it work if I enjoy it this much and nobody is actually paying me?), I come across a lot of personal trainers. Some of my best friends are personal trainers which, besides a lot of dinner party conversation centered around whether squatting too heavy can give you hemorrhoids (it can) or whether you can tell if a client has had plastic surgery (as long as her sports bra fits properly, you can’t), has also given me an opportunity to observe them in their natural habitat - i.e. not personal training. Hanging around them so often, I’ve started to notice a thing or two.
The Good
You can tell a good personal trainer right off the bat. They are the ones that train you with the intent that after a certain period you won’t need them anymore. Instead of making you dependent on them for motivation and exercise routines, they teach you how to make life long healthy habits - whether they’re around kicking your butt or not. I am quite sure that our beloved MizFit and KellyT fit in this category.
The Bad
Another thing I have noticed is that very often they were a member of the Beautiful People Club long before they got ACE certified which begs an interesting chicken/egg conundrum. But more importantly, many of them do things they would never ever tell a client to do.
1. They take performance enhancers. And I’m not talking wheat grass shots or Omega-3 pills (Must that be capitalized? I fear lightning.) One personal trainer I interviewed admitted to taking risky vasodilators, like N.O. Xplode, which besides causing chemists to frown very disapprovingly at the blatant misuse of standard naming conventions - and anyone who remembers high school chemistry knows how serious that is, also happens to have side effects like headaches, dizziness, heart palpitations, cancer and - my personal fave - “Xplosive” diarrhea. Oh yeah, and death. But it totally ups your one-rep max.
2. They do extreme diets. A female personal trainer friend of mine admits that any time she exceeds her “safe” weight, she kicks in the Bodybuilder Diet - boneless, skinless chicken breasts & greens. Which, incidentally, any reader of gossip rags will recognize as the ubiquitous Hollywood Diet. “I eat lean chicken or fish and broccoli and then walk my dog every day! That’s my secret!!” *cough*cigarettescaffeinecocaine*cough* She also ‘fessed up to using dieter’s tea (a laxative), cleanses like the Martha’s Vineyard Diet, and the chew-n-spit method - a favorite of bulimics everywhere. Even the famed Jillian Michaels says she uses diuretics, stimulants and extreme water-loss tricks like sweating it out in the sauna or running on a treadmill with sweats and a jacket on when she needs to get in peak form for a photo shoot.
3. They totally think you look fat in those pants. Of course they would never tell you. Most of them are too polite. The rest of them fancy their paychecks too much. But wringing an honest body assessment out of a personal trainer is like getting child support out of K-Fed. Word to the wise: tighter is not always better, no perfume, and please, for the love of little green apples, wear underwear.
4. They don’t know what they’re talking about. It’s a tough business. There’s so much research coming out, it’s hard to stay on top of it all. So they make stuff up. They take an article they skimmed in 30 seconds and make a whole program out of it with you as their guinea pig. And it will probably work because for 95% of their clients, anything will work. Diet and exercise - you’ve heard of that right?
I should say only the bad ones do these things. But even some of the best ones do them because they’re desperate to stay on top of an industry that is second only to Hollywood in making a career solely out of a nice set of abs. I just thought you might want to know what goes into those abs.
Oh, and in case you thought I forgot “The Ugly”….





June 3rd, 2008 at 6:27 am
I laughed
I cried
this post was better than CATS.
I *so* agree with all of it—but when it’s from The Great Charlotte Experience that goes without saying.
M.
MizFit’s last blog post..Tues Tip.
June 3rd, 2008 at 9:40 am
LMAO hahahaaaa OMG is this what they will say about me when I pass my ACE exam? hahahaaaa HILARIOUS. and that pic.. worth a million words
BK’s last blog post..Reader Question - Motivation
June 3rd, 2008 at 9:57 am
This is just funny. I have never gone the personal trainer route- now if I ever do I will know what to look for/expect. That picture is classic!
Hannah’s last blog post..Lesson Learned
June 3rd, 2008 at 10:00 am
Wow..this was hilarious and so true! Even being a trainer, I can spot the ones that are “just there to get paid” and the ones who truly want to help their clients. I feel sorry clients who aren’t getting what they pay for…
June 3rd, 2008 at 12:47 pm
SO true, and so funny! Charlotte, you rock, as always!
Yes, it’s good to keep in mind that most fitness pros don’t always look the way they do in those photos or on their workout DVDs. That is usually the result of extreme diets and extra workouts done solely for the specific media.
June 3rd, 2008 at 1:06 pm
I’m a member of gold’s gym and so many personal male personal trainers are out of shape and the female personal trainers are anorexics. So…who wants advice from these people when they themselves have a difficult time staying healthy?
June 3rd, 2008 at 2:30 pm
BK - Just use your powers for good and not evil & you’ll be fab;) Good luck on your exam!!
Angie - I’m so glad that there are good ones out there like you. You do really provide a valuable service.
Iris - I’ve had the same thoughts myself many a time…
charlotte’s last blog post..Um, Awkward!
June 3rd, 2008 at 2:30 pm
Thanks for the great post. My last personal trainer was a good one. She trained me every Wednesday at 9am at the Y until she ‘left’ me to start a workout group for new moms. While I miss her motivation (you can do 15 more reps at the higher weight) she did her job and I know what to do and how to do it without her. Now I have my weights and yoga ball at work and sneak in a couple sets here and there, especially when I have a project that I want to avoid.
Jean Christofferson’s last blog post..Assigning Value
June 3rd, 2008 at 2:53 pm
there you go again, makin me spray snot!
Fitarella’s last blog post..Kiss my kettlebell!
June 3rd, 2008 at 4:52 pm
Love this post. Thanks, Charlotte!
Sagan’s last blog post..Hamam Comparison
June 4th, 2008 at 10:16 am
Very funny and true!
Rachel’s last blog post..What I (re)learned in bike camp
June 4th, 2008 at 7:54 pm
That is comically personal! LOL.